{ "cells": [ { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 3, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/12", "audience": 1, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 1, 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 2, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": true, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 1, 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 1, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 2, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 1, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 2, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 2, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 1, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 2, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 2, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "13/8", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/12", "audience": 1, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "13/8", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 1, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "13/8", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 3, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "13/8", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 1, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/12", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 1, 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 2, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": true, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 1, 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "13/8", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/8", "audience": 1, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/16", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 2, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 2, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "13/8", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "37/24", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 2, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 2, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 1, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 1, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/12", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 3, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 1, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "35/24", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 2, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 2, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 1, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "17/12", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 2, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 2, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "45/32", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 1, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "45/32", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/8", "audience": 1, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/16", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "45/32", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 1, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "35/24", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "45/32", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 1, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "45/32", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 2, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 3, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "45/32", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "19/24", "audience": 1, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/48", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 2, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 2, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/24", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 1, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/24", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "37/24", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/24", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 1, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "17/12", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/24", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "19/24", "audience": 1, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/48", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 2, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 2, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/24", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 1, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/24", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 2, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 2 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 3, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 4, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "7/18", "audience": 1, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "4/9", "audience": 2, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 3, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 3, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "4/9", "audience": 1, "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/9", "audience": 2, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 3 ], "weak": [ 3 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 3, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "17/36", "audience": 1, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "11/18", "audience": 2, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 3, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 3 ], "weak": [ 3 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 3, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 1, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 3, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 3 ], "weak": [ 3 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 3, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/32", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "4/9", "audience": 1, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/12", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/18", "audience": 2, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/32", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 1, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/32", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 2, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "13/8", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 3, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 4, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/32", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/9", "audience": 1, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "95/48", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "11/18", "audience": 2, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/12", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 3, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/32", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 1, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "125/64", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/16", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 3, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 2, 3 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 3, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": true, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 2, 3 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/32", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "11/18", "audience": 1, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "185/96", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "13/18", "audience": 2, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "37/24", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 3, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 3 ], "weak": [ 3 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 3, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/36", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/9", "audience": 1, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "2", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "4/9", "audience": 2, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/36", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "11/18", "audience": 1, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "137/72", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/9", "audience": 2, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/12", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 3, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/36", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/36", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 4, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/36", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "25/36", "audience": 1, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "253/144", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "13/18", "audience": 2, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "35/24", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 3, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 3, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/36", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "13/18", "audience": 1, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "41/24", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/9", "audience": 2, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "17/12", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 3, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 3, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "421/256", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "11/18", "audience": 1, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/16", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "17/36", "audience": 2, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "421/256", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "233/128", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 2, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/16", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 3, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "421/256", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "13/18", "audience": 1, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "109/64", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "25/36", "audience": 2, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "35/24", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "421/256", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 1, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "421/256", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 2, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "45/32", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 3, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 4, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "421/256", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "7/9", "audience": 1, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "203/128", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "29/36", "audience": 2, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/48", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 3, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 1, 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 3, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": true, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 1, 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": true, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 1, 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "419/288", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "67/36", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 2, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "419/288", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "13/18", "audience": 1, "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "497/288", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "11/18", "audience": 2, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "37/24", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 3, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "419/288", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "7/9", "audience": 1, "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "229/144", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "13/18", "audience": 2, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "17/12", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "419/288", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "29/36", "audience": 1, "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "877/576", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/9", "audience": 2, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/48", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 3, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "143/144", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 3, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "419/288", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 1, "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "419/288", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 2, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/24", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 3, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 3 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "143/144", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "215/216", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 4, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 5, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "3/8", "audience": 1, "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/12", "audience": 2, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "11/24", "audience": 3, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 4, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 4, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/12", "audience": 1, "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 2, "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 3, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 3, 4 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 4, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": true, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 3, 4 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "7/16", "audience": 1, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 2, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "31/48", "audience": 3, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 4, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 4 ], "weak": [ 4 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 4, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "11/24", "audience": 1, "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 2, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 3, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 4, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "77/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 4 ], "weak": [ 4 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 4, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "295/128", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "11/24", "audience": 1, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "113/48", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/12", "audience": 2, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/12", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/8", "audience": 3, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "295/128", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 1, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "295/128", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 2, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/32", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 3, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "13/8", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 4, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 5, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "295/128", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 1, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "433/192", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 2, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "95/48", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/8", "audience": 3, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/12", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 4, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "295/128", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "9/16", "audience": 1, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "571/256", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/8", "audience": 2, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "125/64", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "11/16", "audience": 3, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/16", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 4, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 3 ], "weak": [ 3 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 4, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "295/128", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 1, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "847/384", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "185/96", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 3, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "37/24", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 4, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 4 ], "weak": [ 4 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 4, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "437/216", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 1, "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "119/54", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 2, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "2", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/12", "audience": 3, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "437/216", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/8", "audience": 1, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "913/432", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 2, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "137/72", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 3, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/12", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 4, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "437/216", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "437/216", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/36", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "80/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 5, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "437/216", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "11/16", "audience": 1, "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "1709/864", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 2, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "253/144", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "35/48", "audience": 3, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "35/24", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 4, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "80/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 4, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "437/216", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 1, "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "835/432", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 2, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "41/24", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "19/24", "audience": 3, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "17/12", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 4, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "80/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 3 ], "weak": [ 3 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 4, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "3735/2048", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "31/48", "audience": 1, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "805/384", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 2, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/16", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "7/16", "audience": 3, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "3735/2048", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "11/16", "audience": 1, "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "2035/1024", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/8", "audience": 2, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "233/128", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "9/16", "audience": 3, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/16", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 4, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "3735/2048", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "35/48", "audience": 1, "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "2885/1536", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 2, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "109/64", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "11/16", "audience": 3, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "35/24", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "3735/2048", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 1, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "3735/2048", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 2, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "421/256", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 3, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "45/32", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 4, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 5, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "3735/2048", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "37/48", "audience": 1, "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "5435/3072", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "19/24", "audience": 2, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "203/128", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "13/16", "audience": 3, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/48", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 4, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 4, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "5485/3456", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 1, "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "851/432", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 2, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "67/36", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "11/24", "audience": 3, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "5485/3456", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 1, "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "6367/3456", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "497/288", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 3, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "37/24", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 4, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "5485/3456", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "19/24", "audience": 1, "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "2963/1728", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 2, "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "229/144", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 3, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "17/12", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "647/648", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "5485/3456", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "13/16", "audience": 1, "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "11411/6912", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "19/24", "audience": 2, "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "877/576", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "37/48", "audience": 3, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/48", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 4, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "647/648", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "863/864", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "143/144", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 4, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "5485/3456", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 1, "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "5485/3456", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 2, "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "419/288", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 3, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/24", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 4, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 4 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "647/648", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "863/864", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "143/144", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "1295/1296", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "215/216", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 5, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 5, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 6, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "11/30", "audience": 1, "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/5", "audience": 2, "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "13/30", "audience": 3, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "7/15", "audience": 4, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 5, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 5, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "2/5", "audience": 1, "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/15", "audience": 2, "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "8/15", "audience": 3, "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "3/5", "audience": 4, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 5, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 4 ], "weak": [ 4 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 5, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/12", "audience": 1, "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 2, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 3, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 5, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "77/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 5 ], "weak": [ 5 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 5, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "13/30", "audience": 1, "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "8/15", "audience": 2, "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "19/30", "audience": 3, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "11/15", "audience": 4, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 5, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "77/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "235/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "77/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 5 ], "weak": [ 5 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 5, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "1277/512", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "7/15", "audience": 1, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "487/192", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "13/30", "audience": 2, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "113/48", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "2/5", "audience": 3, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/12", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "11/30", "audience": 4, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 5, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "1277/512", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 1, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "1277/512", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 2, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "295/128", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 3, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/32", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 4, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "13/8", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 5, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 6, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "1277/512", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "8/15", "audience": 1, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "1883/768", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "17/30", "audience": 2, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "433/192", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/5", "audience": 3, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "95/48", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "19/30", "audience": 4, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/12", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 5, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 5, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "1277/512", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "11/20", "audience": 1, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "2489/1024", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/5", "audience": 2, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "571/256", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "13/20", "audience": 3, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "125/64", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "7/10", "audience": 4, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/16", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 5, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 3 ], "weak": [ 3 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 5, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "1277/512", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "17/30", "audience": 1, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "3701/1536", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "19/30", "audience": 2, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "847/384", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "7/10", "audience": 3, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "185/96", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "23/30", "audience": 4, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "37/24", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 5, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 4, 5 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 5, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": true, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 4, 5 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "947/432", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "3/5", "audience": 1, "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "761/324", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "8/15", "audience": 2, "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "119/54", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "7/15", "audience": 3, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "2", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "2/5", "audience": 4, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 5, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "947/432", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "19/30", "audience": 1, "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "5885/2592", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/5", "audience": 2, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "913/432", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "17/30", "audience": 3, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "137/72", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "8/15", "audience": 4, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/12", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 5, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "947/432", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "947/432", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "437/216", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/36", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 5, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "242/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "80/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 6, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "947/432", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "41/60", "audience": 1, "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "11161/5184", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/10", "audience": 2, "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "1709/864", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "43/60", "audience": 3, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "253/144", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "11/15", "audience": 4, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "35/24", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 5, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "242/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "80/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 5, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "947/432", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "7/10", "audience": 1, "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "5479/2592", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "11/15", "audience": 2, "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "835/432", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "23/30", "audience": 3, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "41/24", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "4/5", "audience": 4, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "17/12", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 5, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "242/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "80/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "485/486", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 3 ], "weak": [ 3 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 5, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "32329/16384", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "2269/1024", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 2, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "805/384", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 3, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/16", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/12", "audience": 4, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 5, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "32329/16384", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "7/10", "audience": 1, "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "17357/8192", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "13/20", "audience": 2, "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "2035/1024", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/5", "audience": 3, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "233/128", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "11/20", "audience": 4, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/16", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 5, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "32329/16384", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "11/15", "audience": 1, "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "8281/4096", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "43/60", "audience": 2, "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "2885/1536", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "7/10", "audience": 3, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "109/64", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "41/60", "audience": 4, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "35/24", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 5, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "767/768", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "32329/16384", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 1, "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "32329/16384", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 2, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "3735/2048", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 3, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "421/256", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 4, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "45/32", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 5, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "767/768", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "1023/1024", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 6, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "32329/16384", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "23/30", "audience": 1, "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "15767/8192", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "47/60", "audience": 2, "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "5435/3072", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "4/5", "audience": 3, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "203/128", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "49/60", "audience": 4, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/48", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 5, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "767/768", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "1023/1024", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 5, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "70727/41472", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "11/15", "audience": 1, "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "10669/5184", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "19/30", "audience": 2, "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "851/432", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "8/15", "audience": 3, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "67/36", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "13/30", "audience": 4, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 5, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "70727/41472", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "23/30", "audience": 1, "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "80477/41472", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/10", "audience": 2, "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "6367/3456", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "19/30", "audience": 3, "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "497/288", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "17/30", "audience": 4, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "37/24", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 5, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2591/2592", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "70727/41472", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "4/5", "audience": 1, "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "37801/20736", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "23/30", "audience": 2, "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "2963/1728", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "11/15", "audience": 3, "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "229/144", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "7/10", "audience": 4, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "17/12", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 5, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2591/2592", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3887/3888", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "647/648", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "70727/41472", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "49/60", "audience": 1, "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "146329/82944", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "4/5", "audience": 2, "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "11411/6912", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "47/60", "audience": 3, "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "877/576", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "23/30", "audience": 4, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/48", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 5, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2591/2592", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3887/3888", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "647/648", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5183/5184", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "863/864", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "143/144", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 5, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "70727/41472", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 1, "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "70727/41472", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "5485/3456", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 3, "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "419/288", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 4, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/24", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 5, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 5 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2591/2592", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3887/3888", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "647/648", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5183/5184", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "863/864", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "143/144", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "7775/7776", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "1295/1296", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "215/216", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 6, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 5, "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 6, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "665/729", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 7, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "13/36", "audience": 1, "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/18", "audience": 2, "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/12", "audience": 3, "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "4/9", "audience": 4, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "17/36", "audience": 5, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 6, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "665/729", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 6, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "7/18", "audience": 1, "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "4/9", "audience": 2, "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 3, "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/9", "audience": 4, "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "11/18", "audience": 5, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 6, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "665/729", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 4 ], "weak": [ 4 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 6, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "29/72", "audience": 1, "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "17/36", "audience": 2, "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 3, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "11/18", "audience": 4, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "49/72", "audience": 5, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 6, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "665/729", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "235/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "77/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 5, 6 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 6, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": true, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 5, 6 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/12", "audience": 1, "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 2, "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 3, "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 5, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 6, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "665/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "235/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "77/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "713/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "235/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "77/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 6 ], "weak": [ 6 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 6, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 6 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 6 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "5383/2048", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "17/36", "audience": 1, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "2045/768", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "4/9", "audience": 2, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "487/192", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/12", "audience": 3, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "113/48", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "7/18", "audience": 4, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/12", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "13/36", "audience": 5, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 6, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "5383/2048", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 1, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "5383/2048", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 2, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "1277/512", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 3, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "295/128", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 4, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/32", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 5, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "13/8", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 6, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 7, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "5383/2048", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "19/36", "audience": 1, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "7969/3072", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/9", "audience": 2, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "1883/768", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 3, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "433/192", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "11/18", "audience": 4, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "95/48", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "23/36", "audience": 5, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/12", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 6, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 6, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "5383/2048", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 1, "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "10555/4096", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 2, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "2489/1024", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/8", "audience": 3, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "571/256", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "125/64", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 5, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/16", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 6, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 4 ], "weak": [ 4 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 6, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "5383/2048", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/9", "audience": 1, "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "15727/6144", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "11/18", "audience": 2, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "3701/1536", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "847/384", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "13/18", "audience": 4, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "185/96", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "7/9", "audience": 5, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "37/24", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 6, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 5 ], "weak": [ 5 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 6, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "18109/7776", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "11/18", "audience": 1, "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "1595/648", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/9", "audience": 2, "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "761/324", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 3, "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "119/54", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "4/9", "audience": 4, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "2", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "7/18", "audience": 5, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 6, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "727/729", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "18109/7776", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "23/36", "audience": 1, "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "37249/15552", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "11/18", "audience": 2, "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "5885/2592", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 3, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "913/432", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/9", "audience": 4, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "137/72", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "19/36", "audience": 5, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/12", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 6, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "727/729", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "485/486", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "18109/7776", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "18109/7776", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "947/432", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "437/216", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/36", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 5, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 6, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "727/729", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "485/486", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "728/729", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "242/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "80/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 7, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "18109/7776", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "49/72", "audience": 1, "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "71405/31104", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "25/36", "audience": 2, "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "11161/5184", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 3, "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "1709/864", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "13/18", "audience": 4, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "253/144", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "53/72", "audience": 5, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "35/24", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 6, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "727/729", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "485/486", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "728/729", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "242/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "80/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "971/972", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 6, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "18109/7776", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "25/36", "audience": 1, "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "11729/5184", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "13/18", "audience": 2, "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "5479/2592", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 3, "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "835/432", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "7/9", "audience": 4, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "41/24", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "29/36", "audience": 5, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "17/12", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 6, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "727/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "485/486", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "728/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "242/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "80/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "971/972", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "1457/1458", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "485/486", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 3 ], "weak": [ 3 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 6, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "275535/131072", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "49/72", "audience": 1, "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "56905/24576", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "11/18", "audience": 2, "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "2269/1024", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 3, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "805/384", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "17/36", "audience": 4, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/16", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "29/72", "audience": 5, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 6, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "275535/131072", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 1, "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "146155/65536", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "17357/8192", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/8", "audience": 3, "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "2035/1024", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 4, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "233/128", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 5, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/16", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 6, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2047/2048", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "275535/131072", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "53/72", "audience": 1, "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "210845/98304", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "13/18", "audience": 2, "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "8281/4096", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 3, "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "2885/1536", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "25/36", "audience": 4, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "109/64", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "49/72", "audience": 5, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "35/24", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 6, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2047/2048", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3071/3072", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "767/768", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "275535/131072", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 1, "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "275535/131072", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "32329/16384", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 3, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "3735/2048", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 4, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "421/256", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 5, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "45/32", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 6, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2047/2048", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3071/3072", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "767/768", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "4095/4096", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "1023/1024", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 7, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "275535/131072", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "55/72", "audience": 1, "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "404915/196608", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/9", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "15767/8192", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "19/24", "audience": 3, "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "5435/3072", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "29/36", "audience": 4, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "203/128", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "59/72", "audience": 5, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/48", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 6, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2047/2048", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3071/3072", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "767/768", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "4095/4096", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "1023/1024", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "6143/6144", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 6, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "902461/497664", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 1, "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "132935/62208", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "10669/5184", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 3, "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "851/432", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 4, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "67/36", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "5/12", "audience": 5, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 6, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11663/11664", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "902461/497664", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "7/9", "audience": 1, "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "1009807/497664", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "13/18", "audience": 2, "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "80477/41472", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "6367/3456", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "11/18", "audience": 4, "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "497/288", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "5/9", "audience": 5, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "37/24", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 6, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11663/11664", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15551/15552", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2591/2592", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "902461/497664", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "29/36", "audience": 1, "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "478067/248832", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/9", "audience": 2, "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "37801/20736", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 3, "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "2963/1728", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "13/18", "audience": 4, "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "229/144", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "25/36", "audience": 5, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "17/12", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 6, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11663/11664", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15551/15552", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2591/2592", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23327/23328", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3887/3888", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "647/648", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "902461/497664", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "59/72", "audience": 1, "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "1858595/995328", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "29/36", "audience": 2, "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "146329/82944", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "19/24", "audience": 3, "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "11411/6912", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "7/9", "audience": 4, "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "877/576", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "55/72", "audience": 5, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/48", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 6, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11663/11664", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15551/15552", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2591/2592", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23327/23328", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3887/3888", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "647/648", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "31103/31104", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5183/5184", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "863/864", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "143/144", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 6, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "902461/497664", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 1, "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "902461/497664", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 2, "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "70727/41472", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 3, "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "5485/3456", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 4, "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "419/288", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 5, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/24", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 6, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 6 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11663/11664", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15551/15552", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2591/2592", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23327/23328", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3887/3888", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "647/648", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "31103/31104", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5183/5184", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "863/864", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "143/144", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "46655/46656", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "7775/7776", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "1295/1296", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "215/216", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 7, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2059/729", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2059/729", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 5, "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 6, "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 7, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2059/2187", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "665/729", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 8, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2059/729", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/14", "audience": 1, "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2059/729", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "8/21", "audience": 2, "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "17/42", "audience": 3, "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "3/7", "audience": 4, "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "19/42", "audience": 5, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "10/21", "audience": 6, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 7, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2059/2187", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "665/729", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 7, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2059/729", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "8/21", "audience": 1, "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2059/729", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/7", "audience": 2, "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "10/21", "audience": 3, "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "11/21", "audience": 4, "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "4/7", "audience": 5, "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "13/21", "audience": 6, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 7, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2059/2187", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "665/729", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2123/2187", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 5 ], "weak": [ 5 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 7, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2059/729", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "11/28", "audience": 1, "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2059/729", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "19/42", "audience": 2, "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "43/84", "audience": 3, "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "4/7", "audience": 4, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "53/84", "audience": 5, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "29/42", "audience": 6, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 7, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2059/2187", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "665/729", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2123/2187", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "713/729", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "235/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "77/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 6 ], "weak": [ 6 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 7, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 6 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 6 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 6 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 6 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2059/729", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "17/42", "audience": 1, "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2059/729", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "10/21", "audience": 2, "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "23/42", "audience": 3, "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "13/21", "audience": 4, "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "29/42", "audience": 5, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "16/21", "audience": 6, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 7, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2059/2187", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "665/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2123/2187", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "713/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "235/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "77/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "2155/2187", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "713/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "235/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "77/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 7 ], "weak": [ 7 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 7, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 6 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 6 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 7 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 7 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "22325/8192", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "10/21", "audience": 1, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "8455/3072", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "19/42", "audience": 2, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "2045/768", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/7", "audience": 3, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "487/192", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "17/42", "audience": 4, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "113/48", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "8/21", "audience": 5, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/12", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "5/14", "audience": 6, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 7, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "22325/8192", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 1, "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "22325/8192", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 2, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "5383/2048", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 3, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "1277/512", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 4, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "295/128", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 5, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/32", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 6, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "13/8", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 7, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 8, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "22325/8192", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "11/21", "audience": 1, "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "33155/12288", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "23/42", "audience": 2, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "7969/3072", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "4/7", "audience": 3, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "1883/768", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "25/42", "audience": 4, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "433/192", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "13/21", "audience": 5, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "95/48", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "9/14", "audience": 6, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/12", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 7, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 3 ], "weak": [ 3 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 7, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "22325/8192", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "15/28", "audience": 1, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "43985/16384", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "4/7", "audience": 2, "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "10555/4096", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "17/28", "audience": 3, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "2489/1024", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "9/14", "audience": 4, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "571/256", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "19/28", "audience": 5, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "125/64", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "5/7", "audience": 6, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/16", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 7, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 4 ], "weak": [ 4 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 7, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "22325/8192", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "23/42", "audience": 1, "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "65645/24576", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "25/42", "audience": 2, "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "15727/6144", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "9/14", "audience": 3, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "3701/1536", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "29/42", "audience": 4, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "847/384", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "31/42", "audience": 5, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "185/96", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "11/14", "audience": 6, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "37/24", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 7, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 6 ], "weak": [ 6 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 7, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 6 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 6 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 6 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 6 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "113905/46656", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "13/21", "audience": 1, "discovery": "2185/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "29773/11664", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "4/7", "audience": 2, "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "1595/648", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "11/21", "audience": 3, "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "761/324", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "10/21", "audience": 4, "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "119/54", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "3/7", "audience": 5, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "2", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "8/21", "audience": 6, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 7, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2185/2187", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "727/729", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2185/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2185/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2185/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2185/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2185/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2185/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2185/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "113905/46656", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "9/14", "audience": 1, "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "232997/93312", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "13/21", "audience": 2, "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "37249/15552", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "25/42", "audience": 3, "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "5885/2592", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "4/7", "audience": 4, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "913/432", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "23/42", "audience": 5, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "137/72", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "11/21", "audience": 6, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/12", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 7, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2185/2187", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "727/729", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1457/1458", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "485/486", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "113905/46656", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "113905/46656", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "18109/7776", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "947/432", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "437/216", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 5, "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/36", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 6, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 7, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2185/2187", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "727/729", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1457/1458", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "485/486", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2186/2187", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "728/729", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "242/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "80/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 8, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "113905/46656", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "19/28", "audience": 1, "discovery": "2915/2916", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "450433/186624", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "29/42", "audience": 2, "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "71405/31104", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "59/84", "audience": 3, "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "11161/5184", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/7", "audience": 4, "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "1709/864", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "61/84", "audience": 5, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "253/144", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "31/42", "audience": 6, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "35/24", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 7, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2185/2187", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "727/729", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1457/1458", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "485/486", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2186/2187", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "728/729", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "242/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "80/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "2915/2916", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "971/972", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 7, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2915/2916", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2915/2916", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2915/2916", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2915/2916", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2915/2916", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2915/2916", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2915/2916", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "113905/46656", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "29/42", "audience": 1, "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "222623/93312", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/7", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "11729/5184", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "31/42", "audience": 3, "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "5479/2592", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "16/21", "audience": 4, "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "835/432", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "11/14", "audience": 5, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "41/24", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "17/21", "audience": 6, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "17/12", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 7, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2185/2187", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "727/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1457/1458", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "485/486", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2186/2187", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "728/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "242/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "80/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "2915/2916", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "971/972", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "4373/4374", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "1457/1458", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "485/486", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 4 ], "weak": [ 4 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 7, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2322121/1048576", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "29/42", "audience": 1, "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "157381/65536", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "53/84", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "56905/24576", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "4/7", "audience": 3, "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "2269/1024", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "43/84", "audience": 4, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "805/384", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "19/42", "audience": 5, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/16", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "11/28", "audience": 6, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 7, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6143/6144", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2322121/1048576", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/7", "audience": 1, "discovery": "8191/8192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "1219853/524288", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "19/28", "audience": 2, "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "146155/65536", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "9/14", "audience": 3, "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "17357/8192", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "17/28", "audience": 4, "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "2035/1024", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "4/7", "audience": 5, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "233/128", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "15/28", "audience": 6, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/16", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 7, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6143/6144", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "8191/8192", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2047/2048", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "8191/8192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "8191/8192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "8191/8192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "8191/8192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "8191/8192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "8191/8192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "8191/8192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2322121/1048576", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "31/42", "audience": 1, "discovery": "12287/12288", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "590329/262144", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "61/84", "audience": 2, "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "210845/98304", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/7", "audience": 3, "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "8281/4096", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "59/84", "audience": 4, "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "2885/1536", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "29/42", "audience": 5, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "109/64", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "19/28", "audience": 6, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "35/24", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 7, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6143/6144", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "8191/8192", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2047/2048", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "12287/12288", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3071/3072", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "767/768", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "12287/12288", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "12287/12288", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "12287/12288", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "12287/12288", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "12287/12288", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "12287/12288", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "12287/12288", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2322121/1048576", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 1, "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2322121/1048576", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 2, "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "275535/131072", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 3, "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "32329/16384", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 4, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "3735/2048", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 5, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "421/256", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 6, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "45/32", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 7, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6143/6144", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "8191/8192", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2047/2048", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "12287/12288", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3071/3072", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "767/768", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "16383/16384", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "4095/4096", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "1023/1024", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 8, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2322121/1048576", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "16/21", "audience": 1, "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "1141463/524288", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "65/84", "audience": 2, "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "404915/196608", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "11/14", "audience": 3, "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "15767/8192", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "67/84", "audience": 4, "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "5435/3072", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "17/21", "audience": 5, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "203/128", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "23/28", "audience": 6, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/48", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 7, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6143/6144", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "8191/8192", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2047/2048", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "12287/12288", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3071/3072", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "767/768", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "16383/16384", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "4095/4096", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "1023/1024", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "24575/24576", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "6143/6144", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 3 ], "weak": [ 3 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 7, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "11420159/5971968", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "16/21", "audience": 1, "discovery": "69983/69984", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "1648957/746496", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "29/42", "audience": 2, "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "132935/62208", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "13/21", "audience": 3, "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "10669/5184", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "23/42", "audience": 4, "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "851/432", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "10/21", "audience": 5, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "67/36", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "17/42", "audience": 6, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 7, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "69983/69984", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11663/11664", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "69983/69984", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "69983/69984", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "69983/69984", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "69983/69984", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "69983/69984", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "69983/69984", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "69983/69984", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "11420159/5971968", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "11/14", "audience": 1, "discovery": "93311/93312", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "12601157/5971968", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "31/42", "audience": 2, "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "1009807/497664", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "29/42", "audience": 3, "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "80477/41472", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "9/14", "audience": 4, "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "6367/3456", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "25/42", "audience": 5, "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "497/288", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "23/42", "audience": 6, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "37/24", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 7, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "69983/69984", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11663/11664", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "93311/93312", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15551/15552", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2591/2592", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "93311/93312", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "93311/93312", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "93311/93312", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "93311/93312", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "93311/93312", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "93311/93312", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "93311/93312", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "11420159/5971968", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "17/21", "audience": 1, "discovery": "139967/139968", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "6005329/2985984", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "11/14", "audience": 2, "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "478067/248832", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "16/21", "audience": 3, "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "37801/20736", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "31/42", "audience": 4, "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "2963/1728", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "5/7", "audience": 5, "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "229/144", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "29/42", "audience": 6, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "17/12", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 7, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "69983/69984", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11663/11664", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "93311/93312", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15551/15552", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2591/2592", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "139967/139968", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23327/23328", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3887/3888", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "647/648", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "139967/139968", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "139967/139968", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "139967/139968", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "139967/139968", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "139967/139968", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "139967/139968", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "139967/139968", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "11420159/5971968", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "23/28", "audience": 1, "discovery": "186623/186624", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "23430817/11943936", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "17/21", "audience": 2, "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "1858595/995328", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "67/84", "audience": 3, "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "146329/82944", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "11/14", "audience": 4, "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "11411/6912", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "65/84", "audience": 5, "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "877/576", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "16/21", "audience": 6, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/48", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 7, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "69983/69984", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11663/11664", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "93311/93312", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15551/15552", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2591/2592", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "139967/139968", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23327/23328", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3887/3888", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "647/648", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "186623/186624", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "31103/31104", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5183/5184", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "863/864", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "143/144", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "186623/186624", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "186623/186624", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "186623/186624", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "186623/186624", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "186623/186624", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "186623/186624", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "186623/186624", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 7, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "11420159/5971968", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 1, "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "11420159/5971968", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 2, "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "902461/497664", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 3, "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "70727/41472", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 4, "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "5485/3456", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 5, "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "419/288", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 6, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/24", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 7, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 7 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "69983/69984", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11663/11664", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "93311/93312", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15551/15552", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2591/2592", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "139967/139968", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23327/23328", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3887/3888", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "647/648", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "186623/186624", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "31103/31104", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5183/5184", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "863/864", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "143/144", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "279935/279936", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "46655/46656", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "7775/7776", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "1295/1296", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "215/216", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 8, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "6305/2187", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "6305/2187", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2059/729", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 5, "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 6, "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 7, "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 8, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6305/6561", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2059/2187", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "665/729", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 9, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2059/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "665/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "211/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "65/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "19/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "6305/2187", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "17/48", "audience": 1, "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "6305/2187", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/8", "audience": 2, "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2059/729", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "19/48", "audience": 3, "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/12", "audience": 4, "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "7/16", "audience": 5, "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "11/24", "audience": 6, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "23/48", "audience": 7, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 8, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6305/6561", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2059/2187", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "665/729", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2123/2187", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 8, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "6305/2187", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "3/8", "audience": 1, "discovery": "6433/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "6305/2187", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/12", "audience": 2, "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2059/729", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "11/24", "audience": 3, "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 4, "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 5, "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 6, "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "5/8", "audience": 7, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 8, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6305/6561", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2059/2187", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "665/729", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2123/2187", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "6433/6561", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2123/2187", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 5 ], "weak": [ 5 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 8, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6433/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6433/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6433/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6433/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6433/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6433/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6433/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6433/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2123/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "697/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "227/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "73/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "23/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "6305/2187", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "37/96", "audience": 1, "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "6305/2187", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/16", "audience": 2, "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2059/729", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "47/96", "audience": 3, "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 4, "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "19/32", "audience": 5, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "31/48", "audience": 6, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "67/96", "audience": 7, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 8, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6305/6561", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2059/2187", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "665/729", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2123/2187", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "6433/6561", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2123/2187", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "2155/2187", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "713/729", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "235/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "77/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 6 ], "weak": [ 6 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 8, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 6 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 6 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 6 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 6 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 6 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 6 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "6305/2187", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "19/48", "audience": 1, "discovery": "6497/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "6305/2187", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "11/24", "audience": 2, "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2059/729", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "25/48", "audience": 3, "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "665/243", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 4, "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "211/81", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "31/48", "audience": 5, "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/27", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 6, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/9", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "37/48", "audience": 7, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 8, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6305/6561", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2059/2187", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "665/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "211/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "65/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "19/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2123/2187", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "6433/6561", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2123/2187", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "697/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "227/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "73/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "2155/2187", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "713/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "235/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "77/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "6497/6561", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "2155/2187", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "713/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "235/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "77/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 8 ], "weak": [ 8 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 8, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/3", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6497/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6497/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6497/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6497/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6497/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6497/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 6 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 6 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6497/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 7 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 7 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6305/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6497/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2155/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "713/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "235/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "77/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 8 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 8 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "91615/32768", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "23/48", "audience": 1, "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "34613/12288", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "11/24", "audience": 2, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "8455/3072", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "7/16", "audience": 3, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "2045/768", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/12", "audience": 4, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "487/192", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "19/48", "audience": 5, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "113/48", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "3/8", "audience": 6, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/12", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "17/48", "audience": 7, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 8, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "91615/32768", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 1, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "91615/32768", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 2, "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "22325/8192", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 3, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "5383/2048", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 4, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "1277/512", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 5, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "295/128", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 6, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/32", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 7, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "13/8", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 8, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 9, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "91615/32768", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "25/48", "audience": 1, "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "136393/49152", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 2, "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "33155/12288", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "9/16", "audience": 3, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "7969/3072", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 4, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "1883/768", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "29/48", "audience": 5, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "433/192", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "5/8", "audience": 6, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "95/48", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "31/48", "audience": 7, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/12", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 8, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 3 ], "weak": [ 3 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 8, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "91615/32768", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "17/32", "audience": 1, "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "181171/65536", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "9/16", "audience": 2, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "43985/16384", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "19/32", "audience": 3, "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "10555/4096", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/8", "audience": 4, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "2489/1024", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "21/32", "audience": 5, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "571/256", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "11/16", "audience": 6, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "125/64", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "23/32", "audience": 7, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/16", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 8, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 5 ], "weak": [ 5 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 8, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 0, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "91615/32768", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 1, "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "270727/98304", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 2, "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "65645/24576", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/8", "audience": 3, "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "15727/6144", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "3701/1536", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 5, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "847/384", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 6, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "185/96", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "19/24", "audience": 7, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "37/24", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 8, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "767/768", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 6 ], "weak": [ 6 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 8, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "1/2", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 5 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 5 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 6 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 6 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 6 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 6 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 6 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 6 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "236519/93312", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/8", "audience": 1, "discovery": "6559/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "183889/69984", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 2, "discovery": "2185/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "29773/11664", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 3, "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "1595/648", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 4, "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "761/324", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "11/24", "audience": 5, "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "119/54", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "5/12", "audience": 6, "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "2", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "3/8", "audience": 7, "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 8, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6559/6561", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2185/2187", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "727/729", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6559/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6559/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2185/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6559/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2185/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6559/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2185/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6559/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2185/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6559/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2185/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6559/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2185/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6559/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2185/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "727/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "241/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "79/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "25/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "236519/93312", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "31/48", "audience": 1, "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "1445113/559872", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/8", "audience": 2, "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "232997/93312", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "29/48", "audience": 3, "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "37249/15552", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 4, "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "5885/2592", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "9/16", "audience": 5, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "913/432", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 6, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "137/72", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "25/48", "audience": 7, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "19/12", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 8, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6559/6561", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2185/2187", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "727/729", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "4373/4374", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1457/1458", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "485/486", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "236519/93312", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 1, "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "236519/93312", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 2, "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "113905/46656", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 3, "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "18109/7776", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "947/432", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 5, "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "437/216", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 6, "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/36", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 7, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 8, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6559/6561", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2185/2187", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "727/729", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "4373/4374", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1457/1458", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "485/486", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "6560/6561", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2186/2187", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "728/729", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "242/243", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "80/81", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 9, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "2186/2187", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "728/729", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "242/243", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "80/81", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "26/27", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "236519/93312", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "65/96", "audience": 1, "discovery": "8747/8748", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "2812229/1119744", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "11/16", "audience": 2, "discovery": "2915/2916", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "450433/186624", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "67/96", "audience": 3, "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "71405/31104", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 4, "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "11161/5184", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "23/32", "audience": 5, "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "1709/864", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "35/48", "audience": 6, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "253/144", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "71/96", "audience": 7, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "35/24", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 8, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6559/6561", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2185/2187", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "727/729", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "4373/4374", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1457/1458", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "485/486", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "6560/6561", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2186/2187", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "728/729", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "242/243", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "80/81", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "8747/8748", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "2915/2916", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "971/972", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 2 ], "weak": [ 2 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 8, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8747/8748", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8747/8748", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2915/2916", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8747/8748", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2915/2916", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8747/8748", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2915/2916", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8747/8748", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2915/2916", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8747/8748", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2915/2916", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8747/8748", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2915/2916", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8747/8748", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2915/2916", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "971/972", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 0, "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "236519/93312", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "11/16", "audience": 1, "discovery": "13121/13122", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "1393115/559872", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 2, "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "222623/93312", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "35/48", "audience": 3, "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "11729/5184", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 4, "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "5479/2592", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "37/48", "audience": 5, "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "835/432", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "19/24", "audience": 6, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "41/24", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "13/16", "audience": 7, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "17/12", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 8, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6559/6561", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "2185/2187", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "727/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "241/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "79/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "25/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "7/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "4373/4374", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1457/1458", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "485/486", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "6560/6561", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2186/2187", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "728/729", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "242/243", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "80/81", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "26/27", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "8747/8748", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "2915/2916", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "971/972", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "13121/13122", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "4373/4374", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "1457/1458", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "485/486", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "161/162", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 4 ], "weak": [ 4 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 8, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "2/3", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "13121/13122", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "13121/13122", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "13121/13122", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "13121/13122", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "13121/13122", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "13121/13122", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "13121/13122", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "6560/6561", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "13121/13122", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4373/4374", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1457/1458", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "485/486", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "161/162", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 4 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 4 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "19400895/8388608", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "67/96", "audience": 1, "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "3894985/1572864", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "31/48", "audience": 2, "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "157381/65536", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "19/32", "audience": 3, "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "56905/24576", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 4, "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "2269/1024", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "47/96", "audience": 5, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "805/384", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "7/16", "audience": 6, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/16", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "37/96", "audience": 7, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 8, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "24575/24576", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6143/6144", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "19400895/8388608", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "23/32", "audience": 1, "discovery": "32767/32768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "10112155/4194304", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "11/16", "audience": 2, "discovery": "8191/8192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "1219853/524288", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "21/32", "audience": 3, "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "146155/65536", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/8", "audience": 4, "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "17357/8192", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "19/32", "audience": 5, "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "2035/1024", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "9/16", "audience": 6, "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "233/128", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "17/32", "audience": 7, "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "25/16", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 8, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "24575/24576", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6143/6144", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "32767/32768", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "8191/8192", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2047/2048", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "32767/32768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "32767/32768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8191/8192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "32767/32768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8191/8192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "32767/32768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8191/8192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "32767/32768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8191/8192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "32767/32768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8191/8192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "32767/32768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8191/8192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "32767/32768", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8191/8192", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2047/2048", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "511/512", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "127/128", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31/32", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7/8", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "19400895/8388608", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "71/96", "audience": 1, "discovery": "49151/49152", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "14756525/6291456", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "35/48", "audience": 2, "discovery": "12287/12288", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "590329/262144", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "23/32", "audience": 3, "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "210845/98304", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 4, "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "8281/4096", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "67/96", "audience": 5, "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "2885/1536", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "11/16", "audience": 6, "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "109/64", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "65/96", "audience": 7, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "35/24", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 8, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "24575/24576", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6143/6144", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "32767/32768", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "8191/8192", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2047/2048", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "49151/49152", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "12287/12288", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3071/3072", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "767/768", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "49151/49152", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "49151/49152", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "12287/12288", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "49151/49152", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "12287/12288", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "49151/49152", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "12287/12288", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "49151/49152", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "12287/12288", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "49151/49152", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "12287/12288", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "49151/49152", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "12287/12288", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "49151/49152", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "12287/12288", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3071/3072", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "767/768", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "191/192", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "47/48", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "19400895/8388608", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 1, "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "19400895/8388608", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 2, "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "2322121/1048576", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 3, "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "275535/131072", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 4, "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "32329/16384", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 5, "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "3735/2048", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 6, "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "421/256", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 7, "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "45/32", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 8, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "24575/24576", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6143/6144", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "32767/32768", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "8191/8192", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2047/2048", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "49151/49152", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "12287/12288", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3071/3072", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "767/768", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "65535/65536", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "16383/16384", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "4095/4096", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "1023/1024", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 9, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "16383/16384", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "4095/4096", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1023/1024", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "255/256", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "63/64", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15/16", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "shared-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 0, "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "19400895/8388608", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "73/96", "audience": 1, "discovery": "98303/98304", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "28689635/12582912", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "37/48", "audience": 2, "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "1141463/524288", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "25/32", "audience": 3, "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "404915/196608", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "19/24", "audience": 4, "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "15767/8192", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "77/96", "audience": 5, "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "5435/3072", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "13/16", "audience": 6, "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "203/128", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "79/96", "audience": 7, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/48", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 8, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "24575/24576", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "6143/6144", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "32767/32768", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "8191/8192", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2047/2048", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "511/512", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "127/128", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "31/32", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "7/8", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "49151/49152", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "12287/12288", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3071/3072", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "767/768", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "191/192", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "47/48", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "65535/65536", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "16383/16384", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "4095/4096", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "1023/1024", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "255/256", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "63/64", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "15/16", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "98303/98304", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "24575/24576", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "6143/6144", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "1535/1536", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "383/384", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "95/96", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 3 ], "weak": [ 3 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 8, "strict": [ 1 ], "weak": [ 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "3/4", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": true, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "98303/98304", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 1 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "98303/98304", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 2 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 2 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "98303/98304", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "98303/98304", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "98303/98304", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "98303/98304", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "98303/98304", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": false, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": true, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "65535/65536", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "98303/98304", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "24575/24576", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "6143/6144", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1535/1536", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "383/384", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "95/96", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 3 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 3 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "143537845/71663616", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "37/48", "audience": 1, "discovery": "419903/419904", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "20378111/8957952", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 2, "discovery": "69983/69984", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "1648957/746496", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "31/48", "audience": 3, "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "132935/62208", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 4, "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "10669/5184", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "25/48", "audience": 5, "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "851/432", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "11/24", "audience": 6, "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "67/36", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "19/48", "audience": 7, "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "5/3", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "1/3", "audience": 8, "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "419903/419904", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "69983/69984", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11663/11664", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "1/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "419903/419904", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "419903/419904", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "69983/69984", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "419903/419904", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "69983/69984", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "419903/419904", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "69983/69984", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "419903/419904", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "69983/69984", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "419903/419904", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "69983/69984", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "419903/419904", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "69983/69984", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "419903/419904", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "69983/69984", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11663/11664", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1943/1944", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "323/324", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "53/54", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "8/9", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "143537845/71663616", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "19/24", "audience": 1, "discovery": "559871/559872", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "156529207/71663616", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 2, "discovery": "93311/93312", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "12601157/5971968", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 3, "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "1009807/497664", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 4, "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "80477/41472", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "5/8", "audience": 5, "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "6367/3456", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "7/12", "audience": 6, "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "497/288", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "13/24", "audience": 7, "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "37/24", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "1/2", "audience": 8, "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "419903/419904", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "69983/69984", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11663/11664", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "559871/559872", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "93311/93312", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15551/15552", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2591/2592", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "1/2", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "1/2", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "559871/559872", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "559871/559872", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "93311/93312", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "559871/559872", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "93311/93312", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "559871/559872", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "93311/93312", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "559871/559872", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "93311/93312", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "559871/559872", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "93311/93312", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "559871/559872", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "93311/93312", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "559871/559872", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "93311/93312", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "15551/15552", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2591/2592", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "431/432", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "71/72", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "11/12", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1/2", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "143537845/71663616", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "13/16", "audience": 1, "discovery": "839807/839808", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "75016763/35831808", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "19/24", "audience": 2, "discovery": "139967/139968", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "6005329/2985984", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "37/48", "audience": 3, "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "478067/248832", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 4, "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "37801/20736", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "35/48", "audience": 5, "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "2963/1728", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "17/24", "audience": 6, "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "229/144", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "11/16", "audience": 7, "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "17/12", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "2/3", "audience": 8, "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "419903/419904", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "69983/69984", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11663/11664", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "559871/559872", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "93311/93312", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15551/15552", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2591/2592", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "839807/839808", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "139967/139968", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23327/23328", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3887/3888", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "647/648", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "2/3", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "2/3", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "839807/839808", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "839807/839808", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "139967/139968", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "839807/839808", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "139967/139968", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "839807/839808", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "139967/139968", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "839807/839808", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "139967/139968", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "839807/839808", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "139967/139968", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "839807/839808", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "139967/139968", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "839807/839808", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "139967/139968", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23327/23328", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3887/3888", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "647/648", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "107/108", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "17/18", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "2/3", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "private-higher", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "143537845/71663616", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "79/96", "audience": 1, "discovery": "1119743/1119744", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "293571371/143327232", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "13/16", "audience": 2, "discovery": "186623/186624", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "23430817/11943936", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "77/96", "audience": 3, "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "1858595/995328", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "19/24", "audience": 4, "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "146329/82944", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "25/32", "audience": 5, "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "11411/6912", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "37/48", "audience": 6, "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "877/576", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "73/96", "audience": 7, "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "65/48", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "3/4", "audience": 8, "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "419903/419904", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "69983/69984", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11663/11664", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "559871/559872", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "93311/93312", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15551/15552", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2591/2592", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "839807/839808", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "139967/139968", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23327/23328", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3887/3888", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "647/648", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "1119743/1119744", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "186623/186624", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "31103/31104", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5183/5184", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "863/864", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "143/144", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "3/4", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 1, "strict": [ 0 ], "weak": [ 0 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "3/4", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1119743/1119744", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1119743/1119744", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "186623/186624", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1119743/1119744", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "186623/186624", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1119743/1119744", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "186623/186624", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1119743/1119744", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "186623/186624", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1119743/1119744", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "186623/186624", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1119743/1119744", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "186623/186624", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1119743/1119744", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "186623/186624", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "31103/31104", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5183/5184", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "863/864", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "143/144", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "23/24", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "3/4", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] } ] }, { "accuracy_relation": "equal", "agents": 8, "binding_audiences": [ { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 0, "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "143537845/71663616", "information_access_count": 0 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 1, "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "expected_distinct_actions": "143537845/71663616", "information_access_count": 1 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 2, "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "expected_distinct_actions": "11420159/5971968", "information_access_count": 2 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 3, "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "expected_distinct_actions": "902461/497664", "information_access_count": 3 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 4, "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "expected_distinct_actions": "70727/41472", "information_access_count": 4 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 5, "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "expected_distinct_actions": "5485/3456", "information_access_count": 5 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 6, "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "expected_distinct_actions": "419/288", "information_access_count": 6 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 7, "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "expected_distinct_actions": "31/24", "information_access_count": 7 }, { "action_quality": "5/6", "audience": 8, "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "information_access_count": 8 } ], "binding_optima": [ 0, 1 ], "garbling_rows": [ { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "419903/419904", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "69983/69984", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "11663/11664", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1943/1944", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "323/324", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "53/54", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "8/9", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/3", "discovery": "1/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "559871/559872", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "93311/93312", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "15551/15552", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "2591/2592", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "431/432", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "71/72", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "11/12", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "1/2", "discovery": "1/2", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "839807/839808", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "139967/139968", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "23327/23328", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "3887/3888", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "647/648", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "107/108", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "17/18", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "2/3", "discovery": "2/3", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "1119743/1119744", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "186623/186624", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "31103/31104", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "5183/5184", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "863/864", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "143/144", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "23/24", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "3/4", "discovery": "3/4", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 1, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": false, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 2, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "279935/279936", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 3, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "46655/46656", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 4, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "7775/7776", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 5, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "1295/1296", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 6, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "215/216", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 7, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "35/36", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true }, { "audience": 8, "delivered_accuracy": "5/6", "discovery": "5/6", "original_accuracy": "5/6", "strictly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true, "weakly_dominated_by_binding_optimum": true } ], "mechanisms": { "binding_exclusive_delivery": { "budget_balance": "unit discovery prize unchanged", "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "implemented_counts": [ 0, 1 ], "strict": null, "weak": null }, "public_equal_split_nonbinding": { "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] }, "public_universal_pooling": { "count_correspondence_matches_optimum": true, "ex_post_budget_balance": true, "expected_external_subsidy": "0", "identity_equilibrium_count": 9, "strict": [], "weak": [ 0, 1 ] } }, "private_accuracy": "5/6", "shared_accuracy": "5/6", "voluntary_audiences": [ { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 0, "binding_use_implemented": true, "has_binding_implementation_gap": false, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 0, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": true, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [ 0 ], "weak_equilibria": [ 0 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 1, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 1, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 2, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 2, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 3, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 3, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 4, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 4, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 5, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 5, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 6, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 6, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 7, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 7, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "all_equilibria_socially_optimal": true, "audience": 8, "binding_use_implemented": false, "has_binding_implementation_gap": true, "has_excessive_use": false, "has_insufficient_use": false, "has_welfare_multiplicity": false, "profiles": [ { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 0, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "1679615/1679616", "effective_action_channels": 8, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 1, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": true }, { "discovery": "279935/279936", "effective_action_channels": 7, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 2, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "46655/46656", "effective_action_channels": 6, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 3, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "7775/7776", "effective_action_channels": 5, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 4, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "1295/1296", "effective_action_channels": 4, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 5, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "215/216", "effective_action_channels": 3, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 6, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "35/36", "effective_action_channels": 2, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 7, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false }, { "discovery": "5/6", "effective_action_channels": 1, "information_access_count": 8, "readers": 8, "strict_equilibrium": false, "weak_equilibrium": false } ], "strict_equilibria": [], "weak_equilibria": [ 0, 1 ] } ] } ], "run_id": "20260721T215811Z_DD-013_09c07448_cdac4fb512", "schema_version": 1 }