{ "boundary": "selectors expose immutable posterior-only selected-equilibrium outputs; signal-ownership-aware equilibria and centralized role allocation are separate", "claim_ids": [ "DD-C-0104", "DD-C-0105", "DD-C-0106", "DD-C-0107", "DD-C-0108", "DD-C-0109", "DD-C-0110" ], "rows": [ { "accuracy": "1/2", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "0", "dependence_index": "0", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "implementation_gap": "1/4", "payoff_per_agent": "3/8" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "payoff_first": "3/8", "payoff_second": "3/8", "strategies": [ "oppose", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "payoff_first": "3/8", "payoff_second": "3/8", "strategies": [ "oppose", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "payoff_first": "3/8", "payoff_second": "3/8", "strategies": [ "follow", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "payoff_first": "3/8", "payoff_second": "3/8", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 6, "worst_pure_discovery": "3/4" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "implementation_gap": "1/4", "payoff_per_agent": "3/8" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1/2", "regime": "degenerate-continuum-selected-half", "unique_in_symmetric_class": false }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "implementation_gap": "1/4", "payoff_per_agent": "3/8" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 16, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/4", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/4", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/4", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/4", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1/2", "agreement_posterior": "1/2", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "1/2", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/6", "dependence_index": "1/6", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "7/12", "discovery": "17/24", "diversity": "5/12", "expected_distinct_actions": "17/12", "implementation_gap": "7/24", "payoff_per_agent": "17/48" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "5/12", "discovery": "19/24", "diversity": "7/12", "payoff_first": "19/48", "payoff_second": "19/48", "strategies": [ "oppose", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "5/12", "discovery": "19/24", "diversity": "7/12", "payoff_first": "19/48", "payoff_second": "19/48", "strategies": [ "follow", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 4, "worst_pure_discovery": "19/24" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "implementation_gap": "1/4", "payoff_per_agent": "3/8" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1/2", "regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "implementation_gap": "1/4", "payoff_per_agent": "3/8" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 16, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "7/24", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "5/24", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "5/24", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "7/24", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1/2", "agreement_posterior": "1/2", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "1/2", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/4", "dependence_index": "1/4", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "5/8", "discovery": "11/16", "diversity": "3/8", "expected_distinct_actions": "11/8", "implementation_gap": "5/16", "payoff_per_agent": "11/32" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "3/8", "discovery": "13/16", "diversity": "5/8", "payoff_first": "13/32", "payoff_second": "13/32", "strategies": [ "oppose", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "3/8", "discovery": "13/16", "diversity": "5/8", "payoff_first": "13/32", "payoff_second": "13/32", "strategies": [ "follow", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 4, "worst_pure_discovery": "13/16" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "implementation_gap": "1/4", "payoff_per_agent": "3/8" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1/2", "regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "implementation_gap": "1/4", "payoff_per_agent": "3/8" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 16, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "5/16", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "3/16", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "3/16", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "5/16", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1/2", "agreement_posterior": "1/2", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "1/2", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/2", "dependence_index": "1/2", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "3/4", "discovery": "5/8", "diversity": "1/4", "expected_distinct_actions": "5/4", "implementation_gap": "3/8", "payoff_per_agent": "5/16" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "1/4", "discovery": "7/8", "diversity": "3/4", "payoff_first": "7/16", "payoff_second": "7/16", "strategies": [ "oppose", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "1/4", "discovery": "7/8", "diversity": "3/4", "payoff_first": "7/16", "payoff_second": "7/16", "strategies": [ "follow", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 4, "worst_pure_discovery": "7/8" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "implementation_gap": "1/4", "payoff_per_agent": "3/8" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1/2", "regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "implementation_gap": "1/4", "payoff_per_agent": "3/8" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 16, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "3/8", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/8", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/8", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "3/8", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1/2", "agreement_posterior": "1/2", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "1/2", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "7/12", "dependence_index": "7/12", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "19/24", "discovery": "29/48", "diversity": "5/24", "expected_distinct_actions": "29/24", "implementation_gap": "19/48", "payoff_per_agent": "29/96" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "5/24", "discovery": "43/48", "diversity": "19/24", "payoff_first": "43/96", "payoff_second": "43/96", "strategies": [ "oppose", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "5/24", "discovery": "43/48", "diversity": "19/24", "payoff_first": "43/96", "payoff_second": "43/96", "strategies": [ "follow", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 4, "worst_pure_discovery": "43/48" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "implementation_gap": "1/4", "payoff_per_agent": "3/8" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1/2", "regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "implementation_gap": "1/4", "payoff_per_agent": "3/8" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 16, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "19/48", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "5/48", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "5/48", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "19/48", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1/2", "agreement_posterior": "1/2", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "1/2", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "3/4", "dependence_index": "3/4", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "7/8", "discovery": "9/16", "diversity": "1/8", "expected_distinct_actions": "9/8", "implementation_gap": "7/16", "payoff_per_agent": "9/32" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "1/8", "discovery": "15/16", "diversity": "7/8", "payoff_first": "15/32", "payoff_second": "15/32", "strategies": [ "oppose", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "1/8", "discovery": "15/16", "diversity": "7/8", "payoff_first": "15/32", "payoff_second": "15/32", "strategies": [ "follow", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 4, "worst_pure_discovery": "15/16" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "implementation_gap": "1/4", "payoff_per_agent": "3/8" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1/2", "regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "implementation_gap": "1/4", "payoff_per_agent": "3/8" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 16, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "7/16", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/16", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/16", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "7/16", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1/2", "agreement_posterior": "1/2", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "1/2", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1", "dependence_index": "1", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1/2", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "1/2", "payoff_per_agent": "1/4" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "oppose", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "follow", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 4, "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "implementation_gap": "1/4", "payoff_per_agent": "3/8" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1/2", "regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/2", "expected_distinct_actions": "3/2", "implementation_gap": "1/4", "payoff_per_agent": "3/8" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1/2", "agreement_posterior": "1/2", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "11/20", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "0", "dependence_index": "1/100", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "11/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "101/200", "discovery": "319/400", "diversity": "99/200", "expected_distinct_actions": "299/200", "implementation_gap": "81/400", "payoff_per_agent": "319/800" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "11/20", "collision": "101/200", "discovery": "319/400", "diversity": "99/200", "payoff_first": "319/800", "payoff_second": "319/800", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "319/400" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "11/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "101/200", "discovery": "319/400", "diversity": "99/200", "expected_distinct_actions": "299/200", "implementation_gap": "81/400", "payoff_per_agent": "319/800" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-2519/40400", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "107/202", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "119/202", "discovery": "297/404", "diversity": "83/202", "expected_distinct_actions": "285/202", "implementation_gap": "107/404", "payoff_per_agent": "297/808" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 16, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "121/202", "81/202" ], "probability": "101/400", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "99/400", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "99/400", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "81/202", "121/202" ], "probability": "101/400", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "161/202", "agreement_posterior": "121/202", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "11/20", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/6", "dependence_index": "7/40", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "11/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "47/80", "discovery": "121/160", "diversity": "33/80", "expected_distinct_actions": "113/80", "implementation_gap": "39/160", "payoff_per_agent": "121/320" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "11/20", "collision": "47/80", "discovery": "121/160", "diversity": "33/80", "payoff_first": "121/320", "payoff_second": "121/320", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "121/160" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "11/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "47/80", "discovery": "121/160", "diversity": "33/80", "expected_distinct_actions": "113/80", "implementation_gap": "39/160", "payoff_per_agent": "121/320" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-143/7520", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "247/470", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "271/470", "discovery": "693/940", "diversity": "199/470", "expected_distinct_actions": "669/470", "implementation_gap": "247/940", "payoff_per_agent": "693/1880" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 16, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "55/94", "39/94" ], "probability": "47/160", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "33/160", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "33/160", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "39/94", "55/94" ], "probability": "47/160", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "71/94", "agreement_posterior": "55/94", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "11/20", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/4", "dependence_index": "103/400", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "11/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "503/800", "discovery": "1177/1600", "diversity": "297/800", "expected_distinct_actions": "1097/800", "implementation_gap": "423/1600", "payoff_per_agent": "1177/3200" }, "gain_class": "positive", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "11/20", "collision": "503/800", "discovery": "1177/1600", "diversity": "297/800", "payoff_first": "1177/3200", "payoff_second": "1177/3200", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "1177/1600" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "11/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "503/800", "discovery": "1177/1600", "diversity": "297/800", "expected_distinct_actions": "1097/800", "implementation_gap": "423/1600", "payoff_per_agent": "1177/3200" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "1969/804800", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "527/1006", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "575/1006", "discovery": "1485/2012", "diversity": "431/1006", "expected_distinct_actions": "1437/1006", "implementation_gap": "527/2012", "payoff_per_agent": "1485/4024" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 16, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "583/1006", "423/1006" ], "probability": "503/1600", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "297/1600", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "297/1600", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "423/1006", "583/1006" ], "probability": "503/1600", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "743/1006", "agreement_posterior": "583/1006", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "11/20", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/2", "dependence_index": "101/200", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "11/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "301/400", "discovery": "539/800", "diversity": "99/400", "expected_distinct_actions": "499/400", "implementation_gap": "261/800", "payoff_per_agent": "539/1600" }, "gain_class": "positive", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "99/400", "discovery": "701/800", "diversity": "301/400", "payoff_first": "621/1600", "payoff_second": "781/1600", "strategies": [ "oppose", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "99/400", "discovery": "701/800", "diversity": "301/400", "payoff_first": "781/1600", "payoff_second": "621/1600", "strategies": [ "follow", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 4, "worst_pure_discovery": "701/800" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "107/202", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "119/202", "discovery": "297/404", "diversity": "83/202", "expected_distinct_actions": "285/202", "implementation_gap": "107/404", "payoff_per_agent": "297/808" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "161/202", "regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "297/60802", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "313/602", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "337/602", "discovery": "891/1204", "diversity": "265/602", "expected_distinct_actions": "867/602", "implementation_gap": "313/1204", "payoff_per_agent": "891/2408" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 16, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "341/602", "261/602" ], "probability": "301/800", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "99/800", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "99/800", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "261/602", "341/602" ], "probability": "301/800", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "421/602", "agreement_posterior": "341/602", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "11/20", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "7/12", "dependence_index": "47/80", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "11/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "127/160", "discovery": "209/320", "diversity": "33/160", "expected_distinct_actions": "193/160", "implementation_gap": "111/320", "payoff_per_agent": "209/640" }, "gain_class": "positive", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "33/160", "discovery": "287/320", "diversity": "127/160", "payoff_first": "51/128", "payoff_second": "319/640", "strategies": [ "oppose", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "33/160", "discovery": "287/320", "diversity": "127/160", "payoff_first": "319/640", "payoff_second": "51/128", "strategies": [ "follow", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 4, "worst_pure_discovery": "287/320" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "247/470", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "271/470", "discovery": "693/940", "diversity": "199/470", "expected_distinct_actions": "669/470", "implementation_gap": "247/940", "payoff_per_agent": "693/1880" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "71/94", "regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "99/29845", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "659/1270", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "707/1270", "discovery": "1881/2540", "diversity": "563/1270", "expected_distinct_actions": "1833/1270", "implementation_gap": "659/2540", "payoff_per_agent": "1881/5080" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 16, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "143/254", "111/254" ], "probability": "127/320", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "33/320", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "33/320", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "111/254", "143/254" ], "probability": "127/320", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "175/254", "agreement_posterior": "143/254", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "11/20", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "3/4", "dependence_index": "301/400", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "11/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "701/800", "discovery": "979/1600", "diversity": "99/800", "expected_distinct_actions": "899/800", "implementation_gap": "621/1600", "payoff_per_agent": "979/3200" }, "gain_class": "positive", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "99/800", "discovery": "1501/1600", "diversity": "701/800", "payoff_first": "1341/3200", "payoff_second": "1661/3200", "strategies": [ "oppose", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "99/800", "discovery": "1501/1600", "diversity": "701/800", "payoff_first": "1661/3200", "payoff_second": "1341/3200", "strategies": [ "follow", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 4, "worst_pure_discovery": "1501/1600" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "313/602", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "337/602", "discovery": "891/1204", "diversity": "265/602", "expected_distinct_actions": "867/602", "implementation_gap": "313/1204", "payoff_per_agent": "891/2408" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "421/602", "regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "297/211001", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "725/1402", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "773/1402", "discovery": "2079/2804", "diversity": "629/1402", "expected_distinct_actions": "2031/1402", "implementation_gap": "725/2804", "payoff_per_agent": "2079/5608" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 16, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "781/1402", "621/1402" ], "probability": "701/1600", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "99/1600", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "99/1600", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "621/1402", "781/1402" ], "probability": "701/1600", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "941/1402", "agreement_posterior": "781/1402", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "11/20", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1", "dependence_index": "1", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "11/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "11/20", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "9/20", "payoff_per_agent": "11/40" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "9/20", "payoff_second": "11/20", "strategies": [ "oppose", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "11/20", "payoff_second": "9/20", "strategies": [ "follow", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 4, "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "103/200", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "109/200", "discovery": "297/400", "diversity": "91/200", "expected_distinct_actions": "291/200", "implementation_gap": "103/400", "payoff_per_agent": "297/800" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "13/20", "regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "103/200", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "109/200", "discovery": "297/400", "diversity": "91/200", "expected_distinct_actions": "291/200", "implementation_gap": "103/400", "payoff_per_agent": "297/800" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "11/20", "9/20" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "9/20", "11/20" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "13/20", "agreement_posterior": "11/20", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "3/5", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "0", "dependence_index": "1/25", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "13/25", "discovery": "21/25", "diversity": "12/25", "expected_distinct_actions": "37/25", "implementation_gap": "4/25", "payoff_per_agent": "21/50" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "collision": "13/25", "discovery": "21/25", "diversity": "12/25", "payoff_first": "21/50", "payoff_second": "21/50", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "21/25" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "13/25", "discovery": "21/25", "diversity": "12/25", "expected_distinct_actions": "37/25", "implementation_gap": "4/25", "payoff_per_agent": "21/50" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-3/25", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "19/25", "discovery": "18/25", "diversity": "6/25", "expected_distinct_actions": "31/25", "implementation_gap": "7/25", "payoff_per_agent": "9/25" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "21/25", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "9/13" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "9/13", "4/13" ], "probability": "13/50", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "6/25", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "6/25", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "9/13" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "4/13", "9/13" ], "probability": "13/50", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "21/25" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "9/13", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "3/5", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/6", "dependence_index": "1/5", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "3/5", "discovery": "4/5", "diversity": "2/5", "expected_distinct_actions": "7/5", "implementation_gap": "1/5", "payoff_per_agent": "2/5" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "collision": "3/5", "discovery": "4/5", "diversity": "2/5", "payoff_first": "2/5", "payoff_second": "2/5", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "4/5" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "3/5", "discovery": "4/5", "diversity": "2/5", "expected_distinct_actions": "7/5", "implementation_gap": "1/5", "payoff_per_agent": "2/5" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-1/10", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "4/5", "discovery": "7/10", "diversity": "1/5", "expected_distinct_actions": "6/5", "implementation_gap": "3/10", "payoff_per_agent": "7/20" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 36, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "2/3", "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ], [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "2/3", "1/3" ], "probability": "3/10", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/5", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/5", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1", "2/3" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ], [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/3", "2/3" ], "probability": "3/10", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "4/5" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "2/3", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "3/5", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/4", "dependence_index": "7/25", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "16/25", "discovery": "39/50", "diversity": "9/25", "expected_distinct_actions": "34/25", "implementation_gap": "11/50", "payoff_per_agent": "39/100" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "collision": "16/25", "discovery": "39/50", "diversity": "9/25", "payoff_first": "39/100", "payoff_second": "39/100", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "39/50" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "16/25", "discovery": "39/50", "diversity": "9/25", "expected_distinct_actions": "34/25", "implementation_gap": "11/50", "payoff_per_agent": "39/100" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-123/1600", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "19/32", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "25/32", "discovery": "45/64", "diversity": "7/32", "expected_distinct_actions": "39/32", "implementation_gap": "19/64", "payoff_per_agent": "45/128" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 16, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "21/32", "11/32" ], "probability": "8/25", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "9/50", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "9/50", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "11/32", "21/32" ], "probability": "8/25", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "31/32", "agreement_posterior": "21/32", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "3/5", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/2", "dependence_index": "13/25", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "19/25", "discovery": "18/25", "diversity": "6/25", "expected_distinct_actions": "31/25", "implementation_gap": "7/25", "payoff_per_agent": "9/25" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "collision": "19/25", "discovery": "18/25", "diversity": "6/25", "payoff_first": "9/25", "payoff_second": "9/25", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "18/25" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "19/25", "discovery": "18/25", "diversity": "6/25", "expected_distinct_actions": "31/25", "implementation_gap": "7/25", "payoff_per_agent": "9/25" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-9/950", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "11/19", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "14/19", "discovery": "27/38", "diversity": "5/19", "expected_distinct_actions": "24/19", "implementation_gap": "11/38", "payoff_per_agent": "27/76" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 16, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "12/19", "7/19" ], "probability": "19/50", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "3/25", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "3/25", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "7/19", "12/19" ], "probability": "19/50", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "17/19", "agreement_posterior": "12/19", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "3/5", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "7/12", "dependence_index": "3/5", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "4/5", "discovery": "7/10", "diversity": "1/5", "expected_distinct_actions": "6/5", "implementation_gap": "3/10", "payoff_per_agent": "7/20" }, "gain_class": "positive", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "1/5", "discovery": "9/10", "diversity": "4/5", "payoff_first": "7/20", "payoff_second": "11/20", "strategies": [ "oppose", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "1/5", "discovery": "9/10", "diversity": "4/5", "payoff_first": "11/20", "payoff_second": "7/20", "strategies": [ "follow", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "collision": "4/5", "discovery": "7/10", "diversity": "1/5", "payoff_first": "7/20", "payoff_second": "7/20", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 5, "worst_pure_discovery": "7/10" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "4/5", "discovery": "7/10", "diversity": "1/5", "expected_distinct_actions": "6/5", "implementation_gap": "3/10", "payoff_per_agent": "7/20" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "1/80", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "23/40", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "29/40", "discovery": "57/80", "diversity": "11/40", "expected_distinct_actions": "51/40", "implementation_gap": "23/80", "payoff_per_agent": "57/160" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 16, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "5/8", "3/8" ], "probability": "2/5", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/10", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/10", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "3/8", "5/8" ], "probability": "2/5", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "7/8", "agreement_posterior": "5/8", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "3/5", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "3/4", "dependence_index": "19/25", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "22/25", "discovery": "33/50", "diversity": "3/25", "expected_distinct_actions": "28/25", "implementation_gap": "17/50", "payoff_per_agent": "33/100" }, "gain_class": "positive", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "3/25", "discovery": "47/50", "diversity": "22/25", "payoff_first": "37/100", "payoff_second": "57/100", "strategies": [ "oppose", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "3/25", "discovery": "47/50", "diversity": "22/25", "payoff_first": "57/100", "payoff_second": "37/100", "strategies": [ "follow", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 4, "worst_pure_discovery": "47/50" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "11/19", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "14/19", "discovery": "27/38", "diversity": "5/19", "expected_distinct_actions": "24/19", "implementation_gap": "11/38", "payoff_per_agent": "27/76" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "17/19", "regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "9/1672", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "25/44", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "31/44", "discovery": "63/88", "diversity": "13/44", "expected_distinct_actions": "57/44", "implementation_gap": "25/88", "payoff_per_agent": "63/176" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 16, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "27/44", "17/44" ], "probability": "11/25", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "3/50", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "3/50", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "17/44", "27/44" ], "probability": "11/25", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "37/44", "agreement_posterior": "27/44", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "3/5", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1", "dependence_index": "1", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "3/5", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "3/5", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "2/5", "payoff_per_agent": "3/10" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "2/5", "payoff_second": "3/5", "strategies": [ "oppose", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "3/5", "payoff_second": "2/5", "strategies": [ "follow", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 4, "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "14/25", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "17/25", "discovery": "18/25", "diversity": "8/25", "expected_distinct_actions": "33/25", "implementation_gap": "7/25", "payoff_per_agent": "9/25" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "4/5", "regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "14/25", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "17/25", "discovery": "18/25", "diversity": "8/25", "expected_distinct_actions": "33/25", "implementation_gap": "7/25", "payoff_per_agent": "9/25" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "3/5", "2/5" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "2/5", "3/5" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "4/5", "agreement_posterior": "3/5", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "13/20", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "0", "dependence_index": "9/100", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "109/200", "discovery": "351/400", "diversity": "91/200", "expected_distinct_actions": "291/200", "implementation_gap": "49/400", "payoff_per_agent": "351/800" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "collision": "109/200", "discovery": "351/400", "diversity": "91/200", "payoff_first": "351/800", "payoff_second": "351/800", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "351/400" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "109/200", "discovery": "351/400", "diversity": "91/200", "expected_distinct_actions": "291/200", "implementation_gap": "49/400", "payoff_per_agent": "351/800" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-91/800", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "309/400", "discovery": "611/800", "diversity": "91/400", "expected_distinct_actions": "491/400", "implementation_gap": "189/800", "payoff_per_agent": "611/1600" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "351/400", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "169/218" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "169/218", "49/218" ], "probability": "109/400", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "91/400", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "91/400", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "169/218" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "49/218", "169/218" ], "probability": "109/400", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "351/400" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "169/218", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "13/20", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/6", "dependence_index": "29/120", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "149/240", "discovery": "403/480", "diversity": "91/240", "expected_distinct_actions": "331/240", "implementation_gap": "77/480", "payoff_per_agent": "403/960" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "collision": "149/240", "discovery": "403/480", "diversity": "91/240", "payoff_first": "403/960", "payoff_second": "403/960", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "403/480" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "149/240", "discovery": "403/480", "diversity": "91/240", "expected_distinct_actions": "331/240", "implementation_gap": "77/480", "payoff_per_agent": "403/960" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-91/960", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "389/480", "discovery": "143/192", "diversity": "91/480", "expected_distinct_actions": "571/480", "implementation_gap": "49/192", "payoff_per_agent": "143/384" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "403/480", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "221/298" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "221/298", "77/298" ], "probability": "149/480", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "91/480", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "91/480", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "221/298" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "77/298", "221/298" ], "probability": "149/480", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "403/480" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "221/298", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "13/20", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/4", "dependence_index": "127/400", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "527/800", "discovery": "1313/1600", "diversity": "273/800", "expected_distinct_actions": "1073/800", "implementation_gap": "287/1600", "payoff_per_agent": "1313/3200" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "collision": "527/800", "discovery": "1313/1600", "diversity": "273/800", "payoff_first": "1313/3200", "payoff_second": "1313/3200", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "1313/1600" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "527/800", "discovery": "1313/1600", "diversity": "273/800", "expected_distinct_actions": "1073/800", "implementation_gap": "287/1600", "payoff_per_agent": "1313/3200" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-273/3200", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1327/1600", "discovery": "2353/3200", "diversity": "273/1600", "expected_distinct_actions": "1873/1600", "implementation_gap": "847/3200", "payoff_per_agent": "2353/6400" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1313/1600", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "767/1054" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "767/1054", "287/1054" ], "probability": "527/1600", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "273/1600", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "273/1600", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "767/1054" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "287/1054", "767/1054" ], "probability": "527/1600", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1313/1600" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "767/1054", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "13/20", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/2", "dependence_index": "109/200", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "309/400", "discovery": "611/800", "diversity": "91/400", "expected_distinct_actions": "491/400", "implementation_gap": "189/800", "payoff_per_agent": "611/1600" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "collision": "309/400", "discovery": "611/800", "diversity": "91/400", "payoff_first": "611/1600", "payoff_second": "611/1600", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "611/800" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "309/400", "discovery": "611/800", "diversity": "91/400", "expected_distinct_actions": "491/400", "implementation_gap": "189/800", "payoff_per_agent": "611/1600" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-91/1600", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "709/800", "discovery": "1131/1600", "diversity": "91/800", "expected_distinct_actions": "891/800", "implementation_gap": "469/1600", "payoff_per_agent": "1131/3200" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "611/800", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "143/206" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "143/206", "63/206" ], "probability": "309/800", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "91/800", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "91/800", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "143/206" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "63/206", "143/206" ], "probability": "309/800", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "611/800" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "143/206", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "13/20", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "7/12", "dependence_index": "149/240", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "389/480", "discovery": "143/192", "diversity": "91/480", "expected_distinct_actions": "571/480", "implementation_gap": "49/192", "payoff_per_agent": "143/384" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "collision": "389/480", "discovery": "143/192", "diversity": "91/480", "payoff_first": "143/384", "payoff_second": "143/384", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "143/192" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "389/480", "discovery": "143/192", "diversity": "91/480", "expected_distinct_actions": "571/480", "implementation_gap": "49/192", "payoff_per_agent": "143/384" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-91/1920", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "869/960", "discovery": "1339/1920", "diversity": "91/960", "expected_distinct_actions": "1051/960", "implementation_gap": "581/1920", "payoff_per_agent": "1339/3840" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "143/192", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "533/778" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "533/778", "245/778" ], "probability": "389/960", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "91/960", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "91/960", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "533/778" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "245/778", "533/778" ], "probability": "389/960", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "143/192" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "533/778", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "13/20", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "3/4", "dependence_index": "309/400", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "709/800", "discovery": "1131/1600", "diversity": "91/800", "expected_distinct_actions": "891/800", "implementation_gap": "469/1600", "payoff_per_agent": "1131/3200" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "collision": "709/800", "discovery": "1131/1600", "diversity": "91/800", "payoff_first": "1131/3200", "payoff_second": "1131/3200", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "1131/1600" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "709/800", "discovery": "1131/1600", "diversity": "91/800", "expected_distinct_actions": "891/800", "implementation_gap": "469/1600", "payoff_per_agent": "1131/3200" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-91/3200", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1509/1600", "discovery": "2171/3200", "diversity": "91/1600", "expected_distinct_actions": "1691/1600", "implementation_gap": "1029/3200", "payoff_per_agent": "2171/6400" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1131/1600", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "949/1418" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "949/1418", "469/1418" ], "probability": "709/1600", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "91/1600", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "91/1600", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "949/1418" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "469/1418", "949/1418" ], "probability": "709/1600", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1131/1600" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "949/1418", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "13/20", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1", "dependence_index": "1", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "13/20", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "13/20", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "7/20", "payoff_per_agent": "13/40" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "7/20", "payoff_second": "13/20", "strategies": [ "oppose", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "13/20", "payoff_second": "7/20", "strategies": [ "follow", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 4, "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "127/200", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "181/200", "discovery": "273/400", "diversity": "19/200", "expected_distinct_actions": "219/200", "implementation_gap": "127/400", "payoff_per_agent": "273/800" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "19/20", "regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "127/200", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "181/200", "discovery": "273/400", "diversity": "19/200", "expected_distinct_actions": "219/200", "implementation_gap": "127/400", "payoff_per_agent": "273/800" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "13/20", "7/20" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "7/20", "13/20" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "19/20", "agreement_posterior": "13/20", "agreement_regime": "interior-anti-crowding", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "2/3", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "0", "dependence_index": "1/9", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "5/9", "discovery": "8/9", "diversity": "4/9", "expected_distinct_actions": "13/9", "implementation_gap": "1/9", "payoff_per_agent": "4/9" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "collision": "5/9", "discovery": "8/9", "diversity": "4/9", "payoff_first": "4/9", "payoff_second": "4/9", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "8/9" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "5/9", "discovery": "8/9", "diversity": "4/9", "expected_distinct_actions": "13/9", "implementation_gap": "1/9", "payoff_per_agent": "4/9" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-1/9", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "7/9", "discovery": "7/9", "diversity": "2/9", "expected_distinct_actions": "11/9", "implementation_gap": "2/9", "payoff_per_agent": "7/18" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "8/9", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "4/5" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "4/5", "1/5" ], "probability": "5/18", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "2/9", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "2/9", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "4/5" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/5", "4/5" ], "probability": "5/18", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "8/9" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "4/5", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "2/3", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/6", "dependence_index": "7/27", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "17/27", "discovery": "23/27", "diversity": "10/27", "expected_distinct_actions": "37/27", "implementation_gap": "4/27", "payoff_per_agent": "23/54" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "collision": "17/27", "discovery": "23/27", "diversity": "10/27", "payoff_first": "23/54", "payoff_second": "23/54", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "23/27" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "17/27", "discovery": "23/27", "diversity": "10/27", "expected_distinct_actions": "37/27", "implementation_gap": "4/27", "payoff_per_agent": "23/54" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-5/54", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "22/27", "discovery": "41/54", "diversity": "5/27", "expected_distinct_actions": "32/27", "implementation_gap": "13/54", "payoff_per_agent": "41/108" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "23/27", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "13/17" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "13/17", "4/17" ], "probability": "17/54", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "5/27", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "5/27", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "13/17" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "4/17", "13/17" ], "probability": "17/54", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "23/27" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "13/17", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "2/3", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/4", "dependence_index": "1/3", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "diversity": "1/3", "expected_distinct_actions": "4/3", "implementation_gap": "1/6", "payoff_per_agent": "5/12" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "collision": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "diversity": "1/3", "payoff_first": "5/12", "payoff_second": "5/12", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "5/6" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "2/3", "discovery": "5/6", "diversity": "1/3", "expected_distinct_actions": "4/3", "implementation_gap": "1/6", "payoff_per_agent": "5/12" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-1/12", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "5/6", "discovery": "3/4", "diversity": "1/6", "expected_distinct_actions": "7/6", "implementation_gap": "1/4", "payoff_per_agent": "3/8" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "5/6", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "3/4" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "3/4", "1/4" ], "probability": "1/3", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/6", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/6", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "3/4" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/4", "3/4" ], "probability": "1/3", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "5/6" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "3/4", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "2/3", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/2", "dependence_index": "5/9", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "7/9", "discovery": "7/9", "diversity": "2/9", "expected_distinct_actions": "11/9", "implementation_gap": "2/9", "payoff_per_agent": "7/18" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "collision": "7/9", "discovery": "7/9", "diversity": "2/9", "payoff_first": "7/18", "payoff_second": "7/18", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "7/9" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "7/9", "discovery": "7/9", "diversity": "2/9", "expected_distinct_actions": "11/9", "implementation_gap": "2/9", "payoff_per_agent": "7/18" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-1/18", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "8/9", "discovery": "13/18", "diversity": "1/9", "expected_distinct_actions": "10/9", "implementation_gap": "5/18", "payoff_per_agent": "13/36" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "7/9", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "5/7" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "5/7", "2/7" ], "probability": "7/18", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/9", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/9", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "5/7" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "2/7", "5/7" ], "probability": "7/18", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "7/9" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "5/7", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "2/3", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "7/12", "dependence_index": "17/27", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "22/27", "discovery": "41/54", "diversity": "5/27", "expected_distinct_actions": "32/27", "implementation_gap": "13/54", "payoff_per_agent": "41/108" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "collision": "22/27", "discovery": "41/54", "diversity": "5/27", "payoff_first": "41/108", "payoff_second": "41/108", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "41/54" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "22/27", "discovery": "41/54", "diversity": "5/27", "expected_distinct_actions": "32/27", "implementation_gap": "13/54", "payoff_per_agent": "41/108" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-5/108", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "49/54", "discovery": "77/108", "diversity": "5/54", "expected_distinct_actions": "59/54", "implementation_gap": "31/108", "payoff_per_agent": "77/216" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "41/54", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "31/44" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "31/44", "13/44" ], "probability": "11/27", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "5/54", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "5/54", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "31/44" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "13/44", "31/44" ], "probability": "11/27", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "41/54" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "31/44", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "2/3", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "3/4", "dependence_index": "7/9", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "8/9", "discovery": "13/18", "diversity": "1/9", "expected_distinct_actions": "10/9", "implementation_gap": "5/18", "payoff_per_agent": "13/36" }, "gain_class": "negative", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "collision": "8/9", "discovery": "13/18", "diversity": "1/9", "payoff_first": "13/36", "payoff_second": "13/36", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 3, "worst_pure_discovery": "13/18" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "8/9", "discovery": "13/18", "diversity": "1/9", "expected_distinct_actions": "10/9", "implementation_gap": "5/18", "payoff_per_agent": "13/36" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "-1/36", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "17/18", "discovery": "25/36", "diversity": "1/18", "expected_distinct_actions": "19/18", "implementation_gap": "11/36", "payoff_per_agent": "25/72" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "13/18", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 4, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "11/16" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "11/16", "5/16" ], "probability": "4/9", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/18", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/2", "1/2" ], "probability": "1/18", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "11/16" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "5/16", "11/16" ], "probability": "4/9", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "13/18" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "11/16", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "2/3", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1", "dependence_index": "1", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "2/3", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "1/3", "payoff_per_agent": "1/3" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "7/12", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "diversity": "1/2", "payoff_first": "1/3", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-0", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/3", "payoff_second": "2/3", "strategies": [ "oppose", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "7/12", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "diversity": "1/2", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/3", "strategies": [ "follow", "constant-0" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "2/3", "payoff_second": "1/3", "strategies": [ "follow", "oppose" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "collision": "1", "discovery": "2/3", "diversity": "0", "payoff_first": "1/3", "payoff_second": "1/3", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "7/12", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "diversity": "1/2", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/3", "strategies": [ "follow", "constant-1" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "1/2", "collision": "0", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "1", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "constant-0" ] }, { "average_action_quality": "7/12", "collision": "1/2", "discovery": "5/6", "diversity": "1/2", "payoff_first": "1/3", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "constant-1", "follow" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 9, "worst_pure_discovery": "2/3" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "2/3", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "1/3", "payoff_per_agent": "1/3" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "2/3", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "2/3", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "1/3", "payoff_per_agent": "1/3" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 9, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "2/3", "1", "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ], [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "2/3", "1/3" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1", "1", "2/3" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 1 ], [ 1, 0 ], [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1/3", "2/3" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "2/3" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "2/3", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "1", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "0", "dependence_index": "1", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 1, "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 1, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1", "0" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "0", "1" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "1", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "1", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/6", "dependence_index": "1", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 1, "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 1, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1", "0" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "0", "1" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "1", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "1", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/4", "dependence_index": "1", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 1, "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 1, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1", "0" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "0", "1" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "1", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "1", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1/2", "dependence_index": "1", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 1, "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 1, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1", "0" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "0", "1" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "1", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "1", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "7/12", "dependence_index": "1", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 1, "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 1, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1", "0" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "0", "1" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "1", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "1", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "3/4", "dependence_index": "1", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 1, "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 1, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1", "0" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "0", "1" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "1", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } }, { "accuracy": "1", "checks": { "centralized_bound": true, "metric_bounds": true, "payoff_budget_private": true, "payoff_budget_shared": true, "private_metric_agreement": true, "private_selection_agreement": true, "shared_metric_agreement": true }, "dependence": "1", "dependence_index": "1", "direct_private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "gain_class": "neutral", "private_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "equilibria": [ { "average_action_quality": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "payoff_first": "1/2", "payoff_second": "1/2", "strategies": [ "follow", "follow" ] } ], "equilibrium_count": 1, "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "private_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "private_selection": { "follow_probability": "1", "regime": "follow", "unique_in_symmetric_class": true }, "selected_sharing_gain": "0", "shared_metrics": { "average_action_quality": "1", "centralized_top_two": "1", "collision": "1", "discovery": "1", "diversity": "0", "expected_distinct_actions": "1", "implementation_gap": "0", "payoff_per_agent": "1/2" }, "shared_pure_correspondence": { "best_pure_discovery": "1", "on_path_global_pure_selection_count": 1, "states": [ { "discoveries": [ "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 0, 0 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "1", "0" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 0, 0 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 0, 1 ] }, { "on_path": false, "probability": "0", "signals": [ 1, 0 ] }, { "discoveries": [ "1" ], "equilibria": [ [ 1, 1 ] ], "on_path": true, "posterior": [ "0", "1" ], "probability": "1/2", "signals": [ 1, 1 ] } ], "worst_pure_discovery": "1" }, "shared_selection": { "agreement_action_probability": "1", "agreement_posterior": "1", "agreement_regime": "pure-agreement", "disagreement_action_probability": "1/2", "disagreement_posterior": "1/2" } } ], "run_id": "20260722T210334Z_DD-022_2376d5b7_ad67765ca8", "schema_version": 1, "source_sha256": { "registry": "98fb7d475365548fcc723603b3c3721e673b0b0423bc89579c411c3252ac54f1", "threshold_certificate": "146dcfba3f74b76285dd9ae83a03bf811ea0ad4a1029b7773d7c5d6079fbd6bf" }, "study_id": "DD-022", "threshold_certificate": { "checks": { "discriminant": true, "interval_inside_unit": true, "lower_sign_negative": true, "polynomial_matches": true, "unique_positive_root": true, "upper_sign_positive": true }, "endpoint_signs": [ "-2251/1562500", "111/15625" ], "exact_positive_root": "(5*sqrt(73)-17)/48", "isolating_interval": [ "2679/5000", "67/125" ], "passed": true, "polynomial_coefficients": [ 24, 17, -16 ] } }