Synthetic Players
Paper PDF

Review round

Round 10 — Explore Science review of v11

v11 → v12 · 96/100, Platinum

Explore Science (external) · 2026-07-30 · 96/100, Platinum · manuscript arc: v11 → v12

Archived record

Twelve minors. Top three: the bootstrap/human-reference coincidence (audited: rounding coincidence), the label-conflict mechanism (learned game-theoretic prior named as a competing explanation), and the leaning-strata support. v12 extended the capsule to all of Phase 3 (320 runs + 20 baselines), audited archived decoding parameters, and reordered the abstract to lead with the latent-propensity posterior. Response rule: every numerical concern is tested independently before prose changes.

Linked in the research graph

Everything connected to this item, in both directions.

Claims

Analysiss

Manuscript versions

  • v12 — near-arXiv preprintSupersededExtends the replay perimeter to all of Phase 3 (320 runs + 20 baselines), adds the independent bootstrap-coincidence audit, full leaning-strata table, matched-lattice entropy reanalysis, and decoding audit; the abstract leads with the latent-propensity posterior.
  • v11 — the post-freeze addendumSupersededAdds the fixed-panel Dirichlet–Jeffreys latent-propensity sensitivity — the uncertainty view that turned “85–96% dominant” into “63–71% medians, prior-dependent dominance” — as an explicit, declared addendum to the frozen v10 (22 pages; margin line numbers removed)..